Advent & Christmas at Messiah
December 1
First Sunday of Advent
The Rector preaches at 8:00am and 10:15am.
The Rev. Jennifer Hughes preaches at 12:00pm.
Advent Family Workshop at 4:00pm
All invited to come and make Advent wreaths, bake cookies and do crafts for Christmas.
December 4, 11 & 18
Advent Morning Eucharist and Discussion at 6:30am
Service led by lay people. All are welcome. After the service people gather for breakfast and discussion.
December 8
Second Sunday of Advent
The Rector preaches at all services.
Advent Festival of Lessons & Carols at 6:00pm
This service features candlelight, readings, carols, and hymns, and is one of the most beautiful of all Anglican liturgies. After the service, a Victorian Christmas-themed reception will take place in the Parish Hall.
December 12
Guadalupe Service at 7:00pm
A bilingual service with red roses, candle procession and traditional Mexican music.
December 15
Third Sunday of Advent
The Rector preaches at 8:00am and 10:15am.
The Rev. Jennifer Hughes preaches at 12:00pm.
December 21
Las Posadas at 5:30pm
The Posadas re-enact Mary and Joseph’s cold and difficult journey from Nazareth to Bethlehem in search of shelter; in Spanish the word means “lodging.” Participants will sing, pray and walk to three homes and return to church for the conclusion. Refreshments and party follows.
December 22
Fourth Sunday of Advent
The Rev. Jim Lee preaches at 8:00am and 10:15am.
The Rector preaches at 12:00pm.
December 24
Christmas Eve Family Service at 4:00pm
A child-friendly service
re-enacting the nativity story. Children of all ages are welcome.
Choral Prelude at 9:15pm
Michelle Temple, harpist with the Pacific Symphony joins the choir led by Dr. David Sheridan in presenting Benjamin Britten’s beautiful piece, A Ceremony of Carols.
Festive Christmas Eve Eucharist at 10:00pm
A festive Eucharist. The Rector preaches.
December 25
Christmas Day Service at 10:00am
The Rev. Jim Lee preaches.
December 29
First Sunday after Christmas
The Rector preaches at all services.
Thanks and Giving - A Sermon by the Rev. Jim Lee (Thanksgiving C)
Lectionary readings
Last week, our nation remembered the 150th anniversary of President Abraham Lincoln’s address at Gettysburg, as well as the 50th anniversary of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. It is hard not to be awed, even haunted, by the 278 words that make up this historic speech, especially in the wan light of that horrific shooting in Dallas just 100 years later. Lincoln’s words seem not only to honor the war dead on that field in Pennsylvania, but for the one killed in Texas: “It is for us the living rather to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us—that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion—that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain, that this nation under God shall have a new birth of freedom, and that government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth.” We know now what many in 1863 didn’t fully appreciate, how resonant these words would be to capture the spirit of what it means to live out our vocation as Americans, as people who live in this land, to strive to live out the better angels of our nature.
When Lincoln began his address with the famous words, “Fourscore and seven years ago out fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation,” he was tapping into an ancient Jewish practice of calling forth a recital, a rehearsal of the salvation story that marked the covenant between God and God’s people. Read the Hebrew scriptures, and you’ll see recitals punctuating the text, beginning often with that elliptical description of Israel’s patriarch Abraham, “A wandering Aramean was my ancestor.” This particular recital from Deuteronomy is read right before the start of the Jewish New Year and the Day of Atonement, as if to remind the people every year of their corporate identity, where they came from and where they might be going, and to renew their commitment to this identity, by retelling the ancient story that binds them together. It is a powerful story of God’s partnership with God’s people, of God witnessing the suffering of Israel, of God bringing the people into the land promised to that wandering Aramean centuries earlier. It is a story that Jews read while in prison camps in Babylon, and yes, a story even read while in the death camps in Poland and Germany.
For sure, there must have been years when those reading this recital and those listening to it must have wondered where God’s promise was, so deep was their suffering, so far the land of milk and honey seemed to be from their reality. And yet it is this dogged persistence within Judaism, this demand to read this story, to remind the people, to remind God, of the covenant made with their ancestor, that we see in Jesus’ invitation to his followers to work for the food that endures. Jesus knew, just as his fellow Jews generations earlier knew, that in the course of a community, of a family, of a person, there are years of abundance and years of poverty, times of celebration and times of mourning. There are days that feel and look just right, and there are days so dark that you and I wonder if morning will ever come. Jesus reminds you and me what this true bread that endures, this bread of life, is: the story, the recital, of God’s collaboration with God’s people in the work of redemption and liberation of all creation. Tell this story over and over, through thick or thin, through good times and bad, with full bellies or empty stomachs. Tell the story of the community, that will sustain the community not in spite of but especially when the chips are down.
When we tell this story, then our response is two fold: first, like the ancient Israelites, like Americans today, we respond with gratitude to the renewal of faith, God’s faith in us, our faith in God. We set our first fruits before God as a reminder that it is this relationship that is the true sustaining bread of life. Thanks. Second, we celebrate! We eat! We feast! We dance and sing. We drink. Some of us drink a wee bit too much! And with whom? “Together with the Levites and the aliens who reside among you”: we open our banquet for our families, those we love, and we open our tables and hearts to those we don’t know, those who are yet strange to us, those marginalized by our society, those who don’t feel like they belong. Giving. This response, this responsibility toward not just our own but to others, to whomever is the Other in our midst, is also how we partake in this enduring Bread of Life, because in doing so we enact the life-giving generosity of God, whose story we tell over and over.
President Lincoln knew something of this story, of this promise, of this response. 150 years ago, a month before he stepped onto the fields of Gettysburg, he penned a proclamation calling on the formation of a national holiday of Thanksgiving, which would eventually occur a few years after his assassination. In this proclamation, he writes of the bounties for which the American people should be grateful even in the midst of a calamitous civil war: “They are the gracious gifts of the Most High God, who, while dealing with us in anger for our sins, hath nevertheless remembered mercy. It has seemed to me fit and proper that they should be solemnly, reverently and gratefully acknowledged as with one heart and one voice by the whole American People. I do therefore invite my fellow citizens in every part of the United States, and also those who are at sea and those who are sojourning in foreign lands, to set apart and observe the last Thursday of November next, as a day of Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens.” Gratitude. Thanks.
And what then should Americans do, how should they respond? Lincoln continues: “And I recommend to them that while offering up the ascriptions justly due to Him for such singular deliverances and blessings, they do also, with humble penitence for our national perverseness and disobedience, commend to His tender care all those who have become widows, orphans, mourners or sufferers in the lamentable civil strife in which we are unavoidably engaged, and fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty Hand to heal the wounds of the nation and to restore it as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquillity and Union.” Giving.
When you and I tell the story of our community, when you and I recite God’s saving work in our lives, and when you and I respond by bringing into our midst the aliens who reside among us, then you and I will have begun to live out this day of Thanksgiving, not only as a day set aside, but a day that points to that community of freedom and courage that shall never perish from the earth.
Last week, our nation remembered the 150th anniversary of President Abraham Lincoln’s address at Gettysburg, as well as the 50th anniversary of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. It is hard not to be awed, even haunted, by the 278 words that make up this historic speech, especially in the wan light of that horrific shooting in Dallas just 100 years later. Lincoln’s words seem not only to honor the war dead on that field in Pennsylvania, but for the one killed in Texas: “It is for us the living rather to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us—that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion—that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain, that this nation under God shall have a new birth of freedom, and that government of the people, by the people, for the people shall not perish from the earth.” We know now what many in 1863 didn’t fully appreciate, how resonant these words would be to capture the spirit of what it means to live out our vocation as Americans, as people who live in this land, to strive to live out the better angels of our nature.
When Lincoln began his address with the famous words, “Fourscore and seven years ago out fathers brought forth on this continent a new nation,” he was tapping into an ancient Jewish practice of calling forth a recital, a rehearsal of the salvation story that marked the covenant between God and God’s people. Read the Hebrew scriptures, and you’ll see recitals punctuating the text, beginning often with that elliptical description of Israel’s patriarch Abraham, “A wandering Aramean was my ancestor.” This particular recital from Deuteronomy is read right before the start of the Jewish New Year and the Day of Atonement, as if to remind the people every year of their corporate identity, where they came from and where they might be going, and to renew their commitment to this identity, by retelling the ancient story that binds them together. It is a powerful story of God’s partnership with God’s people, of God witnessing the suffering of Israel, of God bringing the people into the land promised to that wandering Aramean centuries earlier. It is a story that Jews read while in prison camps in Babylon, and yes, a story even read while in the death camps in Poland and Germany.
For sure, there must have been years when those reading this recital and those listening to it must have wondered where God’s promise was, so deep was their suffering, so far the land of milk and honey seemed to be from their reality. And yet it is this dogged persistence within Judaism, this demand to read this story, to remind the people, to remind God, of the covenant made with their ancestor, that we see in Jesus’ invitation to his followers to work for the food that endures. Jesus knew, just as his fellow Jews generations earlier knew, that in the course of a community, of a family, of a person, there are years of abundance and years of poverty, times of celebration and times of mourning. There are days that feel and look just right, and there are days so dark that you and I wonder if morning will ever come. Jesus reminds you and me what this true bread that endures, this bread of life, is: the story, the recital, of God’s collaboration with God’s people in the work of redemption and liberation of all creation. Tell this story over and over, through thick or thin, through good times and bad, with full bellies or empty stomachs. Tell the story of the community, that will sustain the community not in spite of but especially when the chips are down.
When we tell this story, then our response is two fold: first, like the ancient Israelites, like Americans today, we respond with gratitude to the renewal of faith, God’s faith in us, our faith in God. We set our first fruits before God as a reminder that it is this relationship that is the true sustaining bread of life. Thanks. Second, we celebrate! We eat! We feast! We dance and sing. We drink. Some of us drink a wee bit too much! And with whom? “Together with the Levites and the aliens who reside among you”: we open our banquet for our families, those we love, and we open our tables and hearts to those we don’t know, those who are yet strange to us, those marginalized by our society, those who don’t feel like they belong. Giving. This response, this responsibility toward not just our own but to others, to whomever is the Other in our midst, is also how we partake in this enduring Bread of Life, because in doing so we enact the life-giving generosity of God, whose story we tell over and over.
President Lincoln knew something of this story, of this promise, of this response. 150 years ago, a month before he stepped onto the fields of Gettysburg, he penned a proclamation calling on the formation of a national holiday of Thanksgiving, which would eventually occur a few years after his assassination. In this proclamation, he writes of the bounties for which the American people should be grateful even in the midst of a calamitous civil war: “They are the gracious gifts of the Most High God, who, while dealing with us in anger for our sins, hath nevertheless remembered mercy. It has seemed to me fit and proper that they should be solemnly, reverently and gratefully acknowledged as with one heart and one voice by the whole American People. I do therefore invite my fellow citizens in every part of the United States, and also those who are at sea and those who are sojourning in foreign lands, to set apart and observe the last Thursday of November next, as a day of Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens.” Gratitude. Thanks.
And what then should Americans do, how should they respond? Lincoln continues: “And I recommend to them that while offering up the ascriptions justly due to Him for such singular deliverances and blessings, they do also, with humble penitence for our national perverseness and disobedience, commend to His tender care all those who have become widows, orphans, mourners or sufferers in the lamentable civil strife in which we are unavoidably engaged, and fervently implore the interposition of the Almighty Hand to heal the wounds of the nation and to restore it as soon as may be consistent with the Divine purposes to the full enjoyment of peace, harmony, tranquillity and Union.” Giving.
When you and I tell the story of our community, when you and I recite God’s saving work in our lives, and when you and I respond by bringing into our midst the aliens who reside among us, then you and I will have begun to live out this day of Thanksgiving, not only as a day set aside, but a day that points to that community of freedom and courage that shall never perish from the earth.
A Sermon by the Rev. Ellen Hill (Proper 28C)
Sunday, November 17,2013
Proper 28C
Twenty-sixth Sunday after Pentecost
The Reverend Ellen R. Hill
Lectionary readings
Did you notice that the underlying theme of today’s lessons deals with the relationship between human responsibility and God’s promises and commandments? I think the place where that tension is the clearest is in the passage from the prophet Malachi. For the questions which are raised in the Old Testament lesson are the same questions which tend to nag at you and me today. Frankly, if you stop and think about it they’re the same basic questions which seem to appear as the sub-text of a good many of our Sunday morning scripture readings. Questions such as: Why evil people seem to prosper? Why tragedies so often happen to good people? Why some people have so much, while others are barely surviving. Questions which push us to ask ourselves why we should continue to believe that the universe is moral and the creation good in light of all the evil and crime present in our world. And if this God we say we believe in is a God who really cares about truth and righteousness and is all powerful then why does God let all of this go on year after year? What’s the point of being religious, of believing in God since God certainly doesn’t seem to have an eye on what’s happening in this world God created.
The Jews of the 5th century B.C. were asking those very same questions when the book of Malachi was written. They had just returned from exile in Babylon where they’d been held captive for several centuries. Even though they’d reestablished themselves in Israel things weren’t going very well. The people were feeling very uncomfortable about their relationship with God because they felt that God had failed to keep the covenant. The wicked and those who didn’t keep the law were not only going unpunished but they actually seemed to be prospering which is probably the reason why this Old Treatment book was written in the format of a lawsuit.
You see it’s really God who is in the dock this morning. And the summary of the whole passage says the same thing that we’ve heard over and over again: That those who’ve honored God, those who’ve lived according to God’s commandments will prosper. Unfortunately, that isn’t the way things usually seem to work out, at least not for many of us. That’s also the reason why we’re so often tempted to listen to that quiet voice within us which says that since it seems that the wicked are prospering we’re only being fools in not grabbing for ourselves all that we can like everyone else seems to be doing. I can’t help but think that it’s that mentality, that sense of disillusionment with our understanding of our covenantal relationship with God, that has contributed to the incredible number of ethics violations and criminal convictions that we’ve witnessed among our elected public officials. It’s hard to live your life in anticipation that on the Day of Judgement the righteous will be rewarded or to believe that there’s some Book of Life where your name is written down and your good deeds are noted when everyone else seems to be racing off on fabulous trips, driving expensive cars, buying exquisite clothes and moving from one beautiful house to another while you slog along and only seem to get further and further behind.
What the Old Testament lesson seems to be struggling with is whether people really do go unpunished. Whether they do, in fact, get off scot free. Whether God is as uncaring as God seems to be. Otherwise, why would God let good people suffer? Why would God make it seem that living a good and decent life is as meaningless and as much of a waste of time as it sometimes does? These questions aren’t just our questions or the questions of the 5th century Jews, these questions are humanity’s eternal questions.
Eli Wiesel tells a story in his book A Jew Today about a group of Jewish exiles who were left in the desert without food or water. One evening they collapsed with fatigue and four of them fell asleep but only three awoke. So the father dug a grave for his wife and he and the children recited the Kaddish, which is the Jewish prayer for the dead, and then they continued on their journey. At the end of the next day the three of them lay down for the night but only two of them awoke. So, the father dug a grave for his older son and recited the Kaddish with his remaining son and then they continued on their journey. When night came the old man and his son stretched out but in the morning only the father opened his eyes. After he had dug the grave and buried his last son, this is what he said to God: “Master of the Universe I know what you want. I understand what you’re doing. You want despair to overwhelm me. You want me to cease believing in You, to cease praying to You, to cease invoking your name, to cease glorifying and sanctifying it. Well I tell you NO! NO! A thousand times NO! You shall not succeed! In spite of me and in spite of you I shall shout the Kaddish, which is song of faith, for You and against You. This song You shall not still God of Israel!"
This story reminds us that to quarrel with God is really to pay God the supreme compliment. It means that you take God so seriously that you’re willing to argue with God. It means God’s important enough to be worth your anger for we simply don’t get angry at people or about things that aren’t important to us. That same kind of devout and steadfast faith has been repeated throughout history most recently in the death of camps of the Third Reich where God’s name was invoked in prayer and praise in the face of the gas chambers and the ovens of the crematoria.
So often our modern agony as believers arises from the tension of trying to live in a world which seems out of control, in a relationship with what we believe to be a good and powerful God, when the truth is that God often seems weak and victimized by the world. And if God isn’t weak and victimized, and is in fact all powerful, then God certainly can’t be good and must somehow be responsible for evil and must be called to account. Either God is the executioner at Auschwitz and Dresden and Hiroshima or God was a participant with the rest of the victims. You see there must have been a lot of righteous people who were killed at Nagasaki as well as Coventry. And the question is as fresh today in the debate about the drone strikes and poison gas.
Maybe it’s only by looking at God as a participant in the world’s suffering that we can begin to explain what otherwise seems like the profoundly deafening silence of God in the face of incredible evil. Perhaps part of the answer lies in the fact that there are righteous people scattered among the wicked in every community. And what we must remember as Christians is that even a minority of righteous persons can have a salvific effect on the greater community. Jesus Christ certainly proved that. For on that cross he was utterly alone, completely surrounded by evil doers and mockers, which is why as Christians we can’t all retreat to the safety and seclusion of a cloistered life. God has placed us squarely in the middle of evil and corrupt societies. And in those communities our very presence creates the possibility of new history.
We can see that in a small but powerful way right here in Santa Ana where this parish, as the Body of Christ, has for more than 30 years provided ministries to serve the poor, the homeless, the hungry and the discriminated against in this community. As a result of that action the Church of the Messiah has been a healing and transforming presence in this community. But you cannot reform a community unless you’re identified with it. And to be identified with it means you have to become one with it. So it seems that in the face of the complexity of our lives and the evil which seems to surround us on every side, all we can be sure of is our fundamental understanding that humanity in the end is saved by the lives of righteous persons which may, on occasion, entail sacrifice on our part.
Happiness and enjoyment aren’t the aim of life, spiritual growth is. Even though our faith tells us that this world, with it’s seemingly unjust suffering, isn’t the last word; it doesn’t help to soften the paradox of God’s seeming injustice here and now. For that same God, in whom we place our hope and who has the power and freedom to bestow grace, is also the same God who doesn’t prevent cancer cells from growing in the bodies of children or typhoons from killing thousands of innocent people.
That’s our major problem. The contrast between what we feel should be and what actually is. But if we look at the way Jesus answered questions like these in the Gospels we’ll see that he didn’t make those kind of distinctions. Once when he was asked why the wicked prospered he responded by pointing out that God made the sun to shine and the rain to fall on the just and the unjust alike. Most of us really do know that there is some randomness to life. Even though we don’t like to admit it we also know that the real question in life, and the ultimate question behind all of the questions in today’s lessons, isn’t really about unfairness or why bad things happen to good people. The real question is about our relationship with God.
When the disciples asked Jesus about life’s fairness he forced them to examine their own relationship to God. But that makes uncomfortable and just like those 5th century Jews when you and I find that God’s answers are confusing or frightening we’re tempted to look for answers someplace else. We’re tempted to look for a God who doesn’t demand repentance. A God who doesn’t allow tragedy and suffering to afflict the faithful. The only problem is that the idea that only good things happen to good people died on the same day we hung Jesus on that cross. Because in his act of dying Jesus asks us: Can you trust God in both joy and in pain? Can you let go of your demand that God to God on your terms? Can you love God without linking your love to the particular kind of cards that life deals you? For God’s love doesn’t carry any promises about good or bad except the promise that God won’t let anything worse happen to us than what happened to God’s own son.
That’s why we come to that table on Sundays. To be given the bread and the wine that are the body and blood of Jesus which was broken and spilled on our behalf. For through that act you and I remember and we honor the way that God has responded to our questions about the fairness of life in the gift of the Babe born in Bethlehem. For the way that we as Christians have dealt with the paradox of God’s seeming injustice and this enduring faith of ours has its roots deep in our Jewish heritage which was beautifully summed up by Eli Weisel when he wrote the following:
“There were many periods in our past when we had every right in the world to turn to God and say,‘Enough! Since you seem to approve of all these persecutions, all these outrages, have it Your way! Let Your world go on without Jews! Either You are our partner in history or you are not. If you are, do your share! If you are not we consider ourselves free of our commitment since you choose to break the covenant, so be it! And yet and yet we went on, believing, hoping, invoking God’s name. We did not give up on God! For this is the essence of being Jewish! Never to give up! Never to yield to despair! And so it must be for us as Christians as well! AMEN
Proper 28C
Twenty-sixth Sunday after Pentecost
The Reverend Ellen R. Hill
Lectionary readings
Did you notice that the underlying theme of today’s lessons deals with the relationship between human responsibility and God’s promises and commandments? I think the place where that tension is the clearest is in the passage from the prophet Malachi. For the questions which are raised in the Old Testament lesson are the same questions which tend to nag at you and me today. Frankly, if you stop and think about it they’re the same basic questions which seem to appear as the sub-text of a good many of our Sunday morning scripture readings. Questions such as: Why evil people seem to prosper? Why tragedies so often happen to good people? Why some people have so much, while others are barely surviving. Questions which push us to ask ourselves why we should continue to believe that the universe is moral and the creation good in light of all the evil and crime present in our world. And if this God we say we believe in is a God who really cares about truth and righteousness and is all powerful then why does God let all of this go on year after year? What’s the point of being religious, of believing in God since God certainly doesn’t seem to have an eye on what’s happening in this world God created.
The Jews of the 5th century B.C. were asking those very same questions when the book of Malachi was written. They had just returned from exile in Babylon where they’d been held captive for several centuries. Even though they’d reestablished themselves in Israel things weren’t going very well. The people were feeling very uncomfortable about their relationship with God because they felt that God had failed to keep the covenant. The wicked and those who didn’t keep the law were not only going unpunished but they actually seemed to be prospering which is probably the reason why this Old Treatment book was written in the format of a lawsuit.
You see it’s really God who is in the dock this morning. And the summary of the whole passage says the same thing that we’ve heard over and over again: That those who’ve honored God, those who’ve lived according to God’s commandments will prosper. Unfortunately, that isn’t the way things usually seem to work out, at least not for many of us. That’s also the reason why we’re so often tempted to listen to that quiet voice within us which says that since it seems that the wicked are prospering we’re only being fools in not grabbing for ourselves all that we can like everyone else seems to be doing. I can’t help but think that it’s that mentality, that sense of disillusionment with our understanding of our covenantal relationship with God, that has contributed to the incredible number of ethics violations and criminal convictions that we’ve witnessed among our elected public officials. It’s hard to live your life in anticipation that on the Day of Judgement the righteous will be rewarded or to believe that there’s some Book of Life where your name is written down and your good deeds are noted when everyone else seems to be racing off on fabulous trips, driving expensive cars, buying exquisite clothes and moving from one beautiful house to another while you slog along and only seem to get further and further behind.
What the Old Testament lesson seems to be struggling with is whether people really do go unpunished. Whether they do, in fact, get off scot free. Whether God is as uncaring as God seems to be. Otherwise, why would God let good people suffer? Why would God make it seem that living a good and decent life is as meaningless and as much of a waste of time as it sometimes does? These questions aren’t just our questions or the questions of the 5th century Jews, these questions are humanity’s eternal questions.
Eli Wiesel tells a story in his book A Jew Today about a group of Jewish exiles who were left in the desert without food or water. One evening they collapsed with fatigue and four of them fell asleep but only three awoke. So the father dug a grave for his wife and he and the children recited the Kaddish, which is the Jewish prayer for the dead, and then they continued on their journey. At the end of the next day the three of them lay down for the night but only two of them awoke. So, the father dug a grave for his older son and recited the Kaddish with his remaining son and then they continued on their journey. When night came the old man and his son stretched out but in the morning only the father opened his eyes. After he had dug the grave and buried his last son, this is what he said to God: “Master of the Universe I know what you want. I understand what you’re doing. You want despair to overwhelm me. You want me to cease believing in You, to cease praying to You, to cease invoking your name, to cease glorifying and sanctifying it. Well I tell you NO! NO! A thousand times NO! You shall not succeed! In spite of me and in spite of you I shall shout the Kaddish, which is song of faith, for You and against You. This song You shall not still God of Israel!"
This story reminds us that to quarrel with God is really to pay God the supreme compliment. It means that you take God so seriously that you’re willing to argue with God. It means God’s important enough to be worth your anger for we simply don’t get angry at people or about things that aren’t important to us. That same kind of devout and steadfast faith has been repeated throughout history most recently in the death of camps of the Third Reich where God’s name was invoked in prayer and praise in the face of the gas chambers and the ovens of the crematoria.
So often our modern agony as believers arises from the tension of trying to live in a world which seems out of control, in a relationship with what we believe to be a good and powerful God, when the truth is that God often seems weak and victimized by the world. And if God isn’t weak and victimized, and is in fact all powerful, then God certainly can’t be good and must somehow be responsible for evil and must be called to account. Either God is the executioner at Auschwitz and Dresden and Hiroshima or God was a participant with the rest of the victims. You see there must have been a lot of righteous people who were killed at Nagasaki as well as Coventry. And the question is as fresh today in the debate about the drone strikes and poison gas.
Maybe it’s only by looking at God as a participant in the world’s suffering that we can begin to explain what otherwise seems like the profoundly deafening silence of God in the face of incredible evil. Perhaps part of the answer lies in the fact that there are righteous people scattered among the wicked in every community. And what we must remember as Christians is that even a minority of righteous persons can have a salvific effect on the greater community. Jesus Christ certainly proved that. For on that cross he was utterly alone, completely surrounded by evil doers and mockers, which is why as Christians we can’t all retreat to the safety and seclusion of a cloistered life. God has placed us squarely in the middle of evil and corrupt societies. And in those communities our very presence creates the possibility of new history.
We can see that in a small but powerful way right here in Santa Ana where this parish, as the Body of Christ, has for more than 30 years provided ministries to serve the poor, the homeless, the hungry and the discriminated against in this community. As a result of that action the Church of the Messiah has been a healing and transforming presence in this community. But you cannot reform a community unless you’re identified with it. And to be identified with it means you have to become one with it. So it seems that in the face of the complexity of our lives and the evil which seems to surround us on every side, all we can be sure of is our fundamental understanding that humanity in the end is saved by the lives of righteous persons which may, on occasion, entail sacrifice on our part.
Happiness and enjoyment aren’t the aim of life, spiritual growth is. Even though our faith tells us that this world, with it’s seemingly unjust suffering, isn’t the last word; it doesn’t help to soften the paradox of God’s seeming injustice here and now. For that same God, in whom we place our hope and who has the power and freedom to bestow grace, is also the same God who doesn’t prevent cancer cells from growing in the bodies of children or typhoons from killing thousands of innocent people.
That’s our major problem. The contrast between what we feel should be and what actually is. But if we look at the way Jesus answered questions like these in the Gospels we’ll see that he didn’t make those kind of distinctions. Once when he was asked why the wicked prospered he responded by pointing out that God made the sun to shine and the rain to fall on the just and the unjust alike. Most of us really do know that there is some randomness to life. Even though we don’t like to admit it we also know that the real question in life, and the ultimate question behind all of the questions in today’s lessons, isn’t really about unfairness or why bad things happen to good people. The real question is about our relationship with God.
When the disciples asked Jesus about life’s fairness he forced them to examine their own relationship to God. But that makes uncomfortable and just like those 5th century Jews when you and I find that God’s answers are confusing or frightening we’re tempted to look for answers someplace else. We’re tempted to look for a God who doesn’t demand repentance. A God who doesn’t allow tragedy and suffering to afflict the faithful. The only problem is that the idea that only good things happen to good people died on the same day we hung Jesus on that cross. Because in his act of dying Jesus asks us: Can you trust God in both joy and in pain? Can you let go of your demand that God to God on your terms? Can you love God without linking your love to the particular kind of cards that life deals you? For God’s love doesn’t carry any promises about good or bad except the promise that God won’t let anything worse happen to us than what happened to God’s own son.
That’s why we come to that table on Sundays. To be given the bread and the wine that are the body and blood of Jesus which was broken and spilled on our behalf. For through that act you and I remember and we honor the way that God has responded to our questions about the fairness of life in the gift of the Babe born in Bethlehem. For the way that we as Christians have dealt with the paradox of God’s seeming injustice and this enduring faith of ours has its roots deep in our Jewish heritage which was beautifully summed up by Eli Weisel when he wrote the following:
“There were many periods in our past when we had every right in the world to turn to God and say,‘Enough! Since you seem to approve of all these persecutions, all these outrages, have it Your way! Let Your world go on without Jews! Either You are our partner in history or you are not. If you are, do your share! If you are not we consider ourselves free of our commitment since you choose to break the covenant, so be it! And yet and yet we went on, believing, hoping, invoking God’s name. We did not give up on God! For this is the essence of being Jewish! Never to give up! Never to yield to despair! And so it must be for us as Christians as well! AMEN
Prayer Is the Thread of Justice-A Sermon by the Rev. Jim Lee (Proper 24C)
Proper 24C
Lectionary readings
The late Japanese American author Hisaye Yamamoto wrote a short story some 60 years ago that featured a ten-year old Yoneko Hosoume who, on the night of March 10, 1933, became an atheist. That evening, an earthquake shook her family’s California farm, so the entire family ran from the house and sat through the temblor in a rhubarb patch. “Immediately on learning what all the commotion was about,” Yamamoto writes, “Yoneko began praying to God to end this violence. She entreated God, flattered Him, wheedled Him, commanded Him, but He did not listen to her at all—inexorably, the earth went on rumbling. After three solid hours of silent, desperate prayer, without any results whatsoever, Yoneko began to suspect that God was either powerless, callous, downright cruel, or nonexistent. In the murky night, under a strange moon wearing a pale ring of light, she decided upon the last as the most plausible theory.” All of us like to think that we’ve somehow moved beyond this childish understanding of prayer, of something like a divine telegram or email service to God, where millions, billions of little, relentless missives get sent up to some heavenly computer database, where God clicks on a mouse after hearing the message, “You’ve got prayer!” (That’s from a Jim Carrey and Morgan Freeman movie.) You and I like to imagine that we’re a bit more mindful and mature enough to know that prayer isn’t a clogged customer service line, that if we just keep praying eventually we’ll get through and God will ship our requests in two standard business days. (Though I will be the first to admit that whenever I step on a plane I do plead and bargain, asking God to keep the plane in the air. It’s not that much different from my high school petitions, “God, help me ace this exam and I promise to take out the garbage for a whole week without being asked!”)
There is of course in this morning’s gospel lesson something very much about the need to pray always, to not lose heart, to persevere and persist just as the protagonist of our parable does, the widow wearing down the crooked judge until he relents. But this parable is not principally about the oft-asked but brittle question, “Does prayer work?” but instead call us into the deeper question, how does prayer work? What does prayer do? Recall: widows in this era and place and its particularly brutal forms of patriarchy, without husband or sons, were rendered completely outside boundaries of social and economic security, often relegated to abject poverty and extreme vulnerability. Vulnerable, because without male protection, widows were profoundly alone, isolated, alienated, and thus usually in need of charity, care, protection from the cruel forces of their social worlds. But here’s the surprise, the reversal that is so often the case in Luke’s gospel: it is this woman, the widow, the one who is supposed to be the object of pity and charity, who arises and asks not for mere scraps and leftovers, but demands justice. And she cries out for justice not on the outskirts of town but rather in the very heart of power, the house of the judge so full of hubris that he is in his own way disconnected, isolated, from the life of the community. So here’s the stunning portrait of what prayer is: the 1 percent is confronted by the have-nots, the one who thinks he’s above it all locks eyes with the one who doesn’t have anything, not asking for pity but demanding justice and recognition of her innate dignity. And in demanding to be recognized, the widow has brought this judge also back into the community that he disdained. Justice is not only the recognition of the poor and the marginal; justice is also the recognition by the powerful that ultimately, finally, they are in same boat, this same mortal coil, as everyone else.
This then is why the question to ask about prayer is not whether or not it works, or whether God hears the prayers of God’s people, but rather how prayer works, what kind of work prayer does. Jesus reminds us that prayer is intimately connected to the work of justice, because prayer is the very thread that stitches the fabric of justice, that reminds you and me that we are deeply interconnected, and rebinds us into a single garment of destiny. Prayer might begin as a single call, perhaps the call of someone in isolating despair, of someone plunged into the deepest darkness, the most agonizing alienation: in the hospital room, in a prison cell, on the floor of a bathroom, in a dank alleyway. It can be alone on a weekday here at Messiah, or at the back of the church with a member of the intercessory prayer group, or with a group of dedicated folks who pray for those on our list every week. But when this prayer reaches the heart of God, God’s heart is moved to stir the hearts of God’s people to make room for this cry for justice and recognition. Like faith, each one of us might pray as individuals, but like faith, our prayers are not ours own, alone. At its core, prayer is the language that binds all of us to one another, to remind us to look upon one another and respond to one another as God looks and responds to us: as God’s beloved children, with whom God grieves when we suffer and with whom God rejoices when we are joyful. Prayer then might start from each of us, individually, but it ends with us praying as and in community, reminding us that there is no one outside the family of God, no one left behind and no one too high up.
At its heart then, what prayer does when we pray unceasingly, without losing heart, is to work ever more toward transforming the world to weave this garment of God’s justice. The prophetic Hasidic rabbi, Abraham Joshua Heschel, who marched with Martin Luther King in Selma, Alabama in 1965 in support of the Voting Rights Act, said of his participation that he felt that he was praying with his feet. But of course, it wasn’t just his feet and King’s feet, but the thousands and thousands of feet who walked and marched and prayed for racial justice. It wasn’t just Heschel’s and King’s but the thousands and thousands of voices that sang and hands that clapped. It wasn’t just Heschel and King but 8000 others who walked with the audacious faith that through power of the Spirit spoken and sung, moving with them that spring morning, their prayers would bring ever more closer the beloved community that beat the heart of God by breaking down the walls that separated people from one another, that kept a widow and a judge from seeing in each other the indwelling of the divine. Later, Rabbi Heschel said this about this kind of prayer: “Prayer is meaningless unless it is subversive, unless it seeks to overthrow and to ruin the pyramids of callousness, hatred, opportunism, falsehoods.” Prayer works because it reminds us of God’s words for us, God’s creation: you are, all of you, my beloved; be beloved to each other. At the end of that march, in Montgomery, Heschel heard King preach the prayer of the widow and of God’s response through God’s community praying together: “Somebody's asking, ‘When will the radiant star of hope be plunged against the nocturnal bosom of this lonely night, plucked from weary souls with chains of fear and the manacles of death? How long will justice be crucified, and truth bear it?’ I come to say to you this afternoon, however difficult the moment, however frustrating the hour, it will not be long, because ‘truth crushed to earth will rise again.’ How long? Not long, because ‘no lie can live forever.’ How long? Not long, because ‘you shall reap what you sow.’ How long? Not long, because the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”
Before you and I meet together at this table that God prepares for all, we will stand for the Prayers of the People. It is during this time that we are invited to offer our individual prayers, from the depths of our darkest despairs, our most intimate cries to God. And we bring them all together, collect them, and weave them together so that our prayers are not ours alone, but now prayers shared. And when we do, we pray with our feet and with our voices, our prayers become also our cries for justice, our stand in solidarity with the all those around God’s world who also cry out for justice and recognition. People of Messiah, these words, spoken aloud, whispered, uttered silently in our hearts, are the very words that will move mountains of oppression and despair, because these words enter God’s heart and in turn enter ours. May our prayers together, today, every day, always, stich our hearts together so tightly to God’s that when the widows of our lives coming knocking on our doors, crying out for recognition, we might all be ready to open the doors of our hearts, to beat the heart of God, and say to her, “Welcome home, sister, come. There’s a seat at the table just for you.”
Lectionary readings
The late Japanese American author Hisaye Yamamoto wrote a short story some 60 years ago that featured a ten-year old Yoneko Hosoume who, on the night of March 10, 1933, became an atheist. That evening, an earthquake shook her family’s California farm, so the entire family ran from the house and sat through the temblor in a rhubarb patch. “Immediately on learning what all the commotion was about,” Yamamoto writes, “Yoneko began praying to God to end this violence. She entreated God, flattered Him, wheedled Him, commanded Him, but He did not listen to her at all—inexorably, the earth went on rumbling. After three solid hours of silent, desperate prayer, without any results whatsoever, Yoneko began to suspect that God was either powerless, callous, downright cruel, or nonexistent. In the murky night, under a strange moon wearing a pale ring of light, she decided upon the last as the most plausible theory.” All of us like to think that we’ve somehow moved beyond this childish understanding of prayer, of something like a divine telegram or email service to God, where millions, billions of little, relentless missives get sent up to some heavenly computer database, where God clicks on a mouse after hearing the message, “You’ve got prayer!” (That’s from a Jim Carrey and Morgan Freeman movie.) You and I like to imagine that we’re a bit more mindful and mature enough to know that prayer isn’t a clogged customer service line, that if we just keep praying eventually we’ll get through and God will ship our requests in two standard business days. (Though I will be the first to admit that whenever I step on a plane I do plead and bargain, asking God to keep the plane in the air. It’s not that much different from my high school petitions, “God, help me ace this exam and I promise to take out the garbage for a whole week without being asked!”)
There is of course in this morning’s gospel lesson something very much about the need to pray always, to not lose heart, to persevere and persist just as the protagonist of our parable does, the widow wearing down the crooked judge until he relents. But this parable is not principally about the oft-asked but brittle question, “Does prayer work?” but instead call us into the deeper question, how does prayer work? What does prayer do? Recall: widows in this era and place and its particularly brutal forms of patriarchy, without husband or sons, were rendered completely outside boundaries of social and economic security, often relegated to abject poverty and extreme vulnerability. Vulnerable, because without male protection, widows were profoundly alone, isolated, alienated, and thus usually in need of charity, care, protection from the cruel forces of their social worlds. But here’s the surprise, the reversal that is so often the case in Luke’s gospel: it is this woman, the widow, the one who is supposed to be the object of pity and charity, who arises and asks not for mere scraps and leftovers, but demands justice. And she cries out for justice not on the outskirts of town but rather in the very heart of power, the house of the judge so full of hubris that he is in his own way disconnected, isolated, from the life of the community. So here’s the stunning portrait of what prayer is: the 1 percent is confronted by the have-nots, the one who thinks he’s above it all locks eyes with the one who doesn’t have anything, not asking for pity but demanding justice and recognition of her innate dignity. And in demanding to be recognized, the widow has brought this judge also back into the community that he disdained. Justice is not only the recognition of the poor and the marginal; justice is also the recognition by the powerful that ultimately, finally, they are in same boat, this same mortal coil, as everyone else.
This then is why the question to ask about prayer is not whether or not it works, or whether God hears the prayers of God’s people, but rather how prayer works, what kind of work prayer does. Jesus reminds us that prayer is intimately connected to the work of justice, because prayer is the very thread that stitches the fabric of justice, that reminds you and me that we are deeply interconnected, and rebinds us into a single garment of destiny. Prayer might begin as a single call, perhaps the call of someone in isolating despair, of someone plunged into the deepest darkness, the most agonizing alienation: in the hospital room, in a prison cell, on the floor of a bathroom, in a dank alleyway. It can be alone on a weekday here at Messiah, or at the back of the church with a member of the intercessory prayer group, or with a group of dedicated folks who pray for those on our list every week. But when this prayer reaches the heart of God, God’s heart is moved to stir the hearts of God’s people to make room for this cry for justice and recognition. Like faith, each one of us might pray as individuals, but like faith, our prayers are not ours own, alone. At its core, prayer is the language that binds all of us to one another, to remind us to look upon one another and respond to one another as God looks and responds to us: as God’s beloved children, with whom God grieves when we suffer and with whom God rejoices when we are joyful. Prayer then might start from each of us, individually, but it ends with us praying as and in community, reminding us that there is no one outside the family of God, no one left behind and no one too high up.
At its heart then, what prayer does when we pray unceasingly, without losing heart, is to work ever more toward transforming the world to weave this garment of God’s justice. The prophetic Hasidic rabbi, Abraham Joshua Heschel, who marched with Martin Luther King in Selma, Alabama in 1965 in support of the Voting Rights Act, said of his participation that he felt that he was praying with his feet. But of course, it wasn’t just his feet and King’s feet, but the thousands and thousands of feet who walked and marched and prayed for racial justice. It wasn’t just Heschel’s and King’s but the thousands and thousands of voices that sang and hands that clapped. It wasn’t just Heschel and King but 8000 others who walked with the audacious faith that through power of the Spirit spoken and sung, moving with them that spring morning, their prayers would bring ever more closer the beloved community that beat the heart of God by breaking down the walls that separated people from one another, that kept a widow and a judge from seeing in each other the indwelling of the divine. Later, Rabbi Heschel said this about this kind of prayer: “Prayer is meaningless unless it is subversive, unless it seeks to overthrow and to ruin the pyramids of callousness, hatred, opportunism, falsehoods.” Prayer works because it reminds us of God’s words for us, God’s creation: you are, all of you, my beloved; be beloved to each other. At the end of that march, in Montgomery, Heschel heard King preach the prayer of the widow and of God’s response through God’s community praying together: “Somebody's asking, ‘When will the radiant star of hope be plunged against the nocturnal bosom of this lonely night, plucked from weary souls with chains of fear and the manacles of death? How long will justice be crucified, and truth bear it?’ I come to say to you this afternoon, however difficult the moment, however frustrating the hour, it will not be long, because ‘truth crushed to earth will rise again.’ How long? Not long, because ‘no lie can live forever.’ How long? Not long, because ‘you shall reap what you sow.’ How long? Not long, because the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.”
Before you and I meet together at this table that God prepares for all, we will stand for the Prayers of the People. It is during this time that we are invited to offer our individual prayers, from the depths of our darkest despairs, our most intimate cries to God. And we bring them all together, collect them, and weave them together so that our prayers are not ours alone, but now prayers shared. And when we do, we pray with our feet and with our voices, our prayers become also our cries for justice, our stand in solidarity with the all those around God’s world who also cry out for justice and recognition. People of Messiah, these words, spoken aloud, whispered, uttered silently in our hearts, are the very words that will move mountains of oppression and despair, because these words enter God’s heart and in turn enter ours. May our prayers together, today, every day, always, stich our hearts together so tightly to God’s that when the widows of our lives coming knocking on our doors, crying out for recognition, we might all be ready to open the doors of our hearts, to beat the heart of God, and say to her, “Welcome home, sister, come. There’s a seat at the table just for you.”
Stewardship Sunday-A Sermon by Nancy Whitehead (Proper 22C)
Lectionary readings
Today is officially Stewardship Sunday. Although you’ve heard some discussion about Stewardship over the last few weeks, today is the day Messiah officially sets aside to discuss Stewardship of our resources, our goals for the coming year and the financial commitment we are each making to the parish . Several weeks ago, Father Abel and I negotiated over who should preach today. A true testament to his negotiating skills is that originally I thought I had won. Only after I sat down to really write this homily, did I realized that perhaps I misjudged, and found out exactly how difficult this is.
The reality is that it is tough to discuss money in church. The trepidation which we all bring to this subject of money in church is deep seated and well founded. Although I was not raised in a church going family, the issue of money and church was part of my upbringing. Neither of my parents were religious or church going. Sundays were for sleeping in, late breakfasts and, in those days before we cared about skin cancer, sitting by the pool, at least here in Southern California. As far back as I can remember, my parents said that my sister and I could attend church anyplace and anytime we wanted to, so long as we got ourselves there and home and as long as they didn’t have to make any sort of financial contribution. My earliest memory of church is when I was about 3 or 4 years old, and my sister and I would walk down to the neighborhood little wooden church and go to Sunday school. I vividly remember the Bible story coloring books. It didn’t last long, and we stopped going, although I didn’t quite understand why. Later, my mother said that the church had told my folks that my sister and I couldn’t attend Sunday school unless my parents attended, and gave money to the church. As it was described to me , it became an “us” against “them” sort of situation, and we stopped attending. In my later childhood, I was told about the agoraphobic neighbor who stopped getting visits from the clergy person after she declined the offer to pledge. As an adult, I have heard similar stories which give a decidedly negative “us vs. them” view of church ‘s asking for money—the TV preachers who are always asking for money, and the family run ministry that mostly benefitted the members of the family—with limo rides and mansions. I’m sure you each have a similar story of your own. The theme of most of these stories is generally that the “church” only cares about your money. Often, there is an undercurrent of “what do they do with all the money, anyway” or “why is there so much focus on money? For the people telling these stories, there is a feeling of “us” vs. “them.” Now, I actually don’t know whether or not those stories from my childhood were true—did the little neighborhood church really kick out my 3 year old self because my parents wouldn’t give? Did the Episcopal priest of my hometown really stop visiting my housebound neighbor because she didn’t pledge? Although I actually don’t know whether these stories were factually true, I am absolutely certain that the stories and the perception of “us vs. them” when it comes to churches and money is reality for many people.
This year is my 23rd year as a pledging member of the Church of the Messiah, and probably my 28th year as a regular contributor to an Episcopal church. Each year, I prayerfully consider my pledge, and have continued to work toward tithing. As I was getting ready for this sermon, and thinking about why I give of my money and my time, I found myself going back to those earliest memories. I can clearly remember when that other view of the church and its requests for money was my reality. However, when I fast forward to today, the reality as to why I give to this Church, and my view as to why I am asked to give, are far different than the one I grew up with.
In the first lesson today, we heard Paul’s second letter to Timothy. Although there is some dispute about its origins, tradition says that this letter was written by Paul from prison, shortly before he died, and that it was the last letter he wrote. The letter overflows with love and gratitude for the people he is writing to. This could be written to us here at the Church of the Messiah, today—-
Imagine—you are kept away by some tragedy, and you are writing a letter to someone in Wednesday’s women, or to Men Seeking God, or the choir or any other group here at Messiah:
"I am grateful to God, when I remember you constantly in my prayers night and day. I long to see you so that I may be filled with joy. I am reminded of your sincere faith, a faith that lived first in your grandmother Lois and your mother Eunice and now, I am sure, lives in you."
We could substitute any number of names of our multi generational congregation. But the sentiment is the same—a group of people, held together by love and faith, supporting those in and outside the community in good times and bad, through the grace that was given to us in Christ Jesus. One of the things I truly love about being part of this community for the length of time I have is knowing each person’s human story—here at Messiah, we really are allowed to be human, which means we don’t have to be perfect ,or pretend to be perfect. We can be who we really are. It helps me in my Christian journey to see the ups and downs that others have gone through, --the successes and failures, the births, the deaths, the tragedies and triumphs, and to still be able to see God’s grace in the midst of it all.
So, going back to my early childhood understanding of the reason churches ask for money—there was always some suspicion, or some sense that the churches have all the money they need. I don’t really know the situations in those other church. But, I intimately know the situation here, at the Church of the Messiah. Our clergy and staff do not take vows of poverty, and our building will not maintain itself. In order to do God’s work in this world, this parish needs funding. This funding comes only from the money we, as a parish, raise. Messiah does not currently receive any significant amount of money from investment income. We do not get any money from the diocese or from any other overseeing power. So, that means that all salaries, all expenses, all programs come from the money that we, as a parish, raise. If you really want to know—where does my money go? Or Why are they asking for money again? You can always look at the financial statements, which are posted on the bulletin board outside the office every month. You will see that every dollar spent is contained in the budget, from the amount spent on coffee for coffee hour to the Rector’s salary. And almost all of that comes from the money pledged during Stewardship. One of the goals of this year’s campaign is to be able to hire a full time associate rector or equivalent. There really is too much going on at this church for only one full time priest, even one as talented as Father Abel, so keep this important goal in mind as you make your pledge. You’ll be hearing more about this during the brunch after the service.
In today’s Gospel reading, Jesus asks the disciples
"Who among you would say to your slave who has just come in from ploughing or tending sheep in the field, 'Come here at once and take your place at the table'?"
If you’re like me, when you read this passage, you put yourself in the place of the boss—the slave owner—and thought something like –well I hope that is what I would do—after all, aren’t we supposed to take care of those less fortunate? Aren’t we supposed to treat everyone with respect and dignity? I would be happy to have dinner with those who are working for me. So, it seems wrong somehow that Jesus is suggesting that this is not what would happen.
But, when I read the rest of the passage, I realized that I am not the slave owner at all. Jesus says, "Would you not rather say to the slave, 'Prepare supper for me, put on your apron and serve me while I eat and drink; later you may eat and drink?' Do you thank the slave for doing what was commanded? So you also, when you have done all that you were ordered to do, say, 'We are worthless slaves; we have done only what we ought to have done.'"
We have done only what we ought to have done. That is what we are called to do. What ought to be done. Whether that is giving of our financial resources, of our time, of our talents, we are called to do what ought to be done.
As many of you know, I had the pleasure and honor of serving as the chair of the discernment committee that resulted in Father Abel being called to be with us here. I used to joke that I was building up points in heaven, and I figured that the discernment committee experience gave me enough points for a lifetime. However, that is really not why I give Messiah my time and financial resources. It is not about building up points in heaven.
I give to Messiah because that is what I ought to do. It is not about a later reward. It is about trying to bring the Kingdom to this place, today. I believe that this parish, the Church of the Messiah, Santa Ana, has a special calling to be that place where everyone is welcome and to be a prophetic voice for justice. Whether you have been attending here for thirty years or thirty minutes, we as a community are called to show how a group of diverse people can actually work together, with grace and gratitude, to bring God’s kingdom a bit closer to reality. I believe that is what we are each called to do, and it is not about “Us” v “Them.” It is all Us. Amen.
Today is officially Stewardship Sunday. Although you’ve heard some discussion about Stewardship over the last few weeks, today is the day Messiah officially sets aside to discuss Stewardship of our resources, our goals for the coming year and the financial commitment we are each making to the parish . Several weeks ago, Father Abel and I negotiated over who should preach today. A true testament to his negotiating skills is that originally I thought I had won. Only after I sat down to really write this homily, did I realized that perhaps I misjudged, and found out exactly how difficult this is.
The reality is that it is tough to discuss money in church. The trepidation which we all bring to this subject of money in church is deep seated and well founded. Although I was not raised in a church going family, the issue of money and church was part of my upbringing. Neither of my parents were religious or church going. Sundays were for sleeping in, late breakfasts and, in those days before we cared about skin cancer, sitting by the pool, at least here in Southern California. As far back as I can remember, my parents said that my sister and I could attend church anyplace and anytime we wanted to, so long as we got ourselves there and home and as long as they didn’t have to make any sort of financial contribution. My earliest memory of church is when I was about 3 or 4 years old, and my sister and I would walk down to the neighborhood little wooden church and go to Sunday school. I vividly remember the Bible story coloring books. It didn’t last long, and we stopped going, although I didn’t quite understand why. Later, my mother said that the church had told my folks that my sister and I couldn’t attend Sunday school unless my parents attended, and gave money to the church. As it was described to me , it became an “us” against “them” sort of situation, and we stopped attending. In my later childhood, I was told about the agoraphobic neighbor who stopped getting visits from the clergy person after she declined the offer to pledge. As an adult, I have heard similar stories which give a decidedly negative “us vs. them” view of church ‘s asking for money—the TV preachers who are always asking for money, and the family run ministry that mostly benefitted the members of the family—with limo rides and mansions. I’m sure you each have a similar story of your own. The theme of most of these stories is generally that the “church” only cares about your money. Often, there is an undercurrent of “what do they do with all the money, anyway” or “why is there so much focus on money? For the people telling these stories, there is a feeling of “us” vs. “them.” Now, I actually don’t know whether or not those stories from my childhood were true—did the little neighborhood church really kick out my 3 year old self because my parents wouldn’t give? Did the Episcopal priest of my hometown really stop visiting my housebound neighbor because she didn’t pledge? Although I actually don’t know whether these stories were factually true, I am absolutely certain that the stories and the perception of “us vs. them” when it comes to churches and money is reality for many people.
This year is my 23rd year as a pledging member of the Church of the Messiah, and probably my 28th year as a regular contributor to an Episcopal church. Each year, I prayerfully consider my pledge, and have continued to work toward tithing. As I was getting ready for this sermon, and thinking about why I give of my money and my time, I found myself going back to those earliest memories. I can clearly remember when that other view of the church and its requests for money was my reality. However, when I fast forward to today, the reality as to why I give to this Church, and my view as to why I am asked to give, are far different than the one I grew up with.
In the first lesson today, we heard Paul’s second letter to Timothy. Although there is some dispute about its origins, tradition says that this letter was written by Paul from prison, shortly before he died, and that it was the last letter he wrote. The letter overflows with love and gratitude for the people he is writing to. This could be written to us here at the Church of the Messiah, today—-
Imagine—you are kept away by some tragedy, and you are writing a letter to someone in Wednesday’s women, or to Men Seeking God, or the choir or any other group here at Messiah:
"I am grateful to God, when I remember you constantly in my prayers night and day. I long to see you so that I may be filled with joy. I am reminded of your sincere faith, a faith that lived first in your grandmother Lois and your mother Eunice and now, I am sure, lives in you."
We could substitute any number of names of our multi generational congregation. But the sentiment is the same—a group of people, held together by love and faith, supporting those in and outside the community in good times and bad, through the grace that was given to us in Christ Jesus. One of the things I truly love about being part of this community for the length of time I have is knowing each person’s human story—here at Messiah, we really are allowed to be human, which means we don’t have to be perfect ,or pretend to be perfect. We can be who we really are. It helps me in my Christian journey to see the ups and downs that others have gone through, --the successes and failures, the births, the deaths, the tragedies and triumphs, and to still be able to see God’s grace in the midst of it all.
So, going back to my early childhood understanding of the reason churches ask for money—there was always some suspicion, or some sense that the churches have all the money they need. I don’t really know the situations in those other church. But, I intimately know the situation here, at the Church of the Messiah. Our clergy and staff do not take vows of poverty, and our building will not maintain itself. In order to do God’s work in this world, this parish needs funding. This funding comes only from the money we, as a parish, raise. Messiah does not currently receive any significant amount of money from investment income. We do not get any money from the diocese or from any other overseeing power. So, that means that all salaries, all expenses, all programs come from the money that we, as a parish, raise. If you really want to know—where does my money go? Or Why are they asking for money again? You can always look at the financial statements, which are posted on the bulletin board outside the office every month. You will see that every dollar spent is contained in the budget, from the amount spent on coffee for coffee hour to the Rector’s salary. And almost all of that comes from the money pledged during Stewardship. One of the goals of this year’s campaign is to be able to hire a full time associate rector or equivalent. There really is too much going on at this church for only one full time priest, even one as talented as Father Abel, so keep this important goal in mind as you make your pledge. You’ll be hearing more about this during the brunch after the service.
In today’s Gospel reading, Jesus asks the disciples
"Who among you would say to your slave who has just come in from ploughing or tending sheep in the field, 'Come here at once and take your place at the table'?"
If you’re like me, when you read this passage, you put yourself in the place of the boss—the slave owner—and thought something like –well I hope that is what I would do—after all, aren’t we supposed to take care of those less fortunate? Aren’t we supposed to treat everyone with respect and dignity? I would be happy to have dinner with those who are working for me. So, it seems wrong somehow that Jesus is suggesting that this is not what would happen.
But, when I read the rest of the passage, I realized that I am not the slave owner at all. Jesus says, "Would you not rather say to the slave, 'Prepare supper for me, put on your apron and serve me while I eat and drink; later you may eat and drink?' Do you thank the slave for doing what was commanded? So you also, when you have done all that you were ordered to do, say, 'We are worthless slaves; we have done only what we ought to have done.'"
We have done only what we ought to have done. That is what we are called to do. What ought to be done. Whether that is giving of our financial resources, of our time, of our talents, we are called to do what ought to be done.
As many of you know, I had the pleasure and honor of serving as the chair of the discernment committee that resulted in Father Abel being called to be with us here. I used to joke that I was building up points in heaven, and I figured that the discernment committee experience gave me enough points for a lifetime. However, that is really not why I give Messiah my time and financial resources. It is not about building up points in heaven.
I give to Messiah because that is what I ought to do. It is not about a later reward. It is about trying to bring the Kingdom to this place, today. I believe that this parish, the Church of the Messiah, Santa Ana, has a special calling to be that place where everyone is welcome and to be a prophetic voice for justice. Whether you have been attending here for thirty years or thirty minutes, we as a community are called to show how a group of diverse people can actually work together, with grace and gratitude, to bring God’s kingdom a bit closer to reality. I believe that is what we are each called to do, and it is not about “Us” v “Them.” It is all Us. Amen.
Seeing Lazarus - A Sermon by Jim Lee (Proper 21C)
Lectionary readings
If you’re like me, you might be of two or more minds about this story that Luke has Jesus tell in our gospel lesson this morning. Or perhaps, maybe it’s not split minds, but split hearts that produce a tension in the response you and I might have to this story. On the one hand, there is this sense that our basic commitment to fairness, to justice, maybe to just desserts, has been accomplished in this story. Perhaps only those inclined to sociopathy actually enjoy seeing people suffer; none of us wants poor Lazarus to be so afflicted with poverty, illness, and alienation, and our hearts are healed to witness him in the lap of the great patriarch Abraham, who caresses him as a mother tends to her baby. Perhaps, if we’re honest with ourselves, you and I might even admit to a bit of schadenfreude, that German word that wonderfully expresses and codes its meaning in English – to derive pleasure from another’s misfortune. A rich man, whom Christian tradition calls Dives (which means “rich man” in Latin), has lived and enjoyed social privilege all his life, ignoring Lazarus lying at his doorstep. There is something in us as Americans, perhaps as human beings, to root for the underdog, to cheer when the spoiled rich get their comeuppance, when the down and out get a shot at wholeness and happiness.
On the other hand, there’s something in our US culture and psyche that makes me grieve a bit at Dives’ final lot: consigned to Hades, eternally in torment, father Abraham seems sorrowful at the fact that this chasm, this gap between Dives and Lazarus, between Hades and Abraham is too great to bridge. The story ends without redemption or transformation for the rich man, or for those of his kind. He doesn’t get to wake up like Ebenezer Scrooge does in Dickens’s novel, transformed, gleeful, ready to give away his wealth to Cratchit and especially Tiny Tim. We steeped in American culture love almost more than the rags-to-riches story the story of someone who learns the hard way that ultimately the accumulation of things doesn’t really hold the secret to life, but rather that what’s important is our attendance to our fellow human beings. We want conversion, we want redemption, we want transformation. But this morning, we’re left with tragedy. Yes, perhaps we have the justice that Mary was talking about at the beginning of Luke, where the lowly are lifted up and where the rich are sent away empty. But this ending still feels hollow. One person’s suffering is alleviated just as another’s is about to begin. If God’s justice is really about feeling delight in this passive kind of revenge, then you and I might wonder: is this the great good news promised to us by our Savior?
The Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. preached on this very passage five days before he was assassinated in 1968. In the following, King focuses on why the rich man finds himself in Hades, “Dives did not go to hell because he was rich; Dives didn't realize that his wealth was his opportunity. It was his opportunity to bridge the gulf that separated him from his brother, Lazarus. Dives went to hell because he passed by Lazarus every day and he never really saw him. He went to hell because he allowed his brother to become invisible. Dives went to hell because he maximized the minimum and minimized the maximum.” If I read King correctly here, then perhaps what this story reveals is not so much a warning to Jesus’ listeners, those in the 1st century, and you and me today, that the rich and wealthy will find themselves in some horrific hellfire of an afterlife. If I read his reading correctly, what King is suggesting is that Dives started creating his own hell the moment that he walked past Lazarus and couldn't see him as a brother, a fellow human being, and one who was clearly a human being in deep need. Dives didn’t go to hell after he died because of what he did or didn’t do on earth – minimizing the maximum and maximizing the minimum—no, Dives was already in hell when he died, a hell that looked, smelled and tasted fine because he had all the money and privilege in the world to make what he was doing look elegant and pretty, but really was building the hell that he wakes up into all too late.
This then is the tragedy that isn’t the end of the story, but rather the tragedy that begins the story that is revealed at the end of his life. The psalmist in Psalm 14 begins by saying “fools say to themselves, ‘there is no God.’” I think that Jesus is echoing the Psalmist by suggesting where God is in this story: fools say to themselves, I have no need for others. Or to put it in a different way: I have no need for those whom I consider the Other, those not like me, those whose lives are so different from mine that I cannot recognize the humanity, the divine spark, in them. What Jesus says through this story is that it is in this Other, this person whom we do not see, whom we do not want to see as God’s beloved, that God comes to us, where God dwells most presently, beckoning us to respond. For Dives, the destitute Lazarus was God coming as the Other; for some, Lazarus is someone with a disability or illness who threatens our fantasy of everlasting health and ablebodiedness. Lazarus is the one consigned to the margins of the social worlds that you and I inhabit and have built up: those pushed to the edges because of their sexuality, their race, their undocumented status, their particular faith or lack of it. Those whom we know dwell amongst us, but for one reason or another we cannot bring ourselves to bring around our table, but rather keep at arm’s length, their difference so great, their suffering so vast that we’d rather bunker up, close the door, so that we can keep up the pretense that the world that we have built just so will remain that way.
You see, God calls you and me to attend to and care for our poorer sisters and brothers, those in our community that have felt the pang of ostracism, not only because it is the just thing to do, not only because in doing so we alleviate individual and collective suffering—make no mistake, these are good things. God calls you and me to work for justice and dignity for all human beings, which means that we fight for shelter, food, healthcare, for those who have the least. But just as important, perhaps more importantly, you and I are called to look at, engage, and attend to the Lazaruses in our lives because when we truly see Lazarus for who he is—however and whoever Lazarus is in your and my life—then we will have emerged from our hells and begun to walk into the field of God. God comes to us as Lazarus, vulnerable, suffering, and in doing so invites us to tend and care, not just to help the less fortunate, but to transform our hearts into the heart of God. We don’t need Lazarus resurrected to prove to us that this is what God’s realm looks like: Abraham tell Dives that his family should look to Moses and the prophets. And if you and I do so, when you and I embrace what the prophets proclaim, then we will have experienced what Dives unfortunately never does: what Lutheran priest and author Nadia Bolz-Weber, riffing off the prophet Jeremiah, calls a “divine heart transplant,” where God takes our hearts of stone, hearts of stone created by the idolatries of wealth, accumulation, the false sense of fear and security, and replaces them with hearts of flesh that beat for God’s people and for God who comes to us as Lazarus.
The late great poet Audre Lorde once addressed a group of feminist activists and concluded her speech with the following: “I urge each one of us here to reach down into that deep place of knowledge inside herself and touch that terror and loathing of any difference that lives there. See whose face it wears.” Jesus invites you and me to meet Lazarus at our doorsteps, the ones under our noses that we have trouble seeing, and beckons us to see in the one in front of us suffering the God who suffers with and as Lazarus. Jesus calls us to come out of the hells of our self-imposed alienation, our gated communities and gated hearts, so that we can beat warm hearts of flesh to help heal God’s beautiful broken world, and to heal our beautiful broken selves. Like Moses and the prophets, Jesus implores us to undergo divine heart transplants so that as we care for all the Lazaruses in our lives, we might all find ourselves in Abraham’s bosom, on earth as it is in heaven.
If you’re like me, you might be of two or more minds about this story that Luke has Jesus tell in our gospel lesson this morning. Or perhaps, maybe it’s not split minds, but split hearts that produce a tension in the response you and I might have to this story. On the one hand, there is this sense that our basic commitment to fairness, to justice, maybe to just desserts, has been accomplished in this story. Perhaps only those inclined to sociopathy actually enjoy seeing people suffer; none of us wants poor Lazarus to be so afflicted with poverty, illness, and alienation, and our hearts are healed to witness him in the lap of the great patriarch Abraham, who caresses him as a mother tends to her baby. Perhaps, if we’re honest with ourselves, you and I might even admit to a bit of schadenfreude, that German word that wonderfully expresses and codes its meaning in English – to derive pleasure from another’s misfortune. A rich man, whom Christian tradition calls Dives (which means “rich man” in Latin), has lived and enjoyed social privilege all his life, ignoring Lazarus lying at his doorstep. There is something in us as Americans, perhaps as human beings, to root for the underdog, to cheer when the spoiled rich get their comeuppance, when the down and out get a shot at wholeness and happiness.
On the other hand, there’s something in our US culture and psyche that makes me grieve a bit at Dives’ final lot: consigned to Hades, eternally in torment, father Abraham seems sorrowful at the fact that this chasm, this gap between Dives and Lazarus, between Hades and Abraham is too great to bridge. The story ends without redemption or transformation for the rich man, or for those of his kind. He doesn’t get to wake up like Ebenezer Scrooge does in Dickens’s novel, transformed, gleeful, ready to give away his wealth to Cratchit and especially Tiny Tim. We steeped in American culture love almost more than the rags-to-riches story the story of someone who learns the hard way that ultimately the accumulation of things doesn’t really hold the secret to life, but rather that what’s important is our attendance to our fellow human beings. We want conversion, we want redemption, we want transformation. But this morning, we’re left with tragedy. Yes, perhaps we have the justice that Mary was talking about at the beginning of Luke, where the lowly are lifted up and where the rich are sent away empty. But this ending still feels hollow. One person’s suffering is alleviated just as another’s is about to begin. If God’s justice is really about feeling delight in this passive kind of revenge, then you and I might wonder: is this the great good news promised to us by our Savior?
The Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. preached on this very passage five days before he was assassinated in 1968. In the following, King focuses on why the rich man finds himself in Hades, “Dives did not go to hell because he was rich; Dives didn't realize that his wealth was his opportunity. It was his opportunity to bridge the gulf that separated him from his brother, Lazarus. Dives went to hell because he passed by Lazarus every day and he never really saw him. He went to hell because he allowed his brother to become invisible. Dives went to hell because he maximized the minimum and minimized the maximum.” If I read King correctly here, then perhaps what this story reveals is not so much a warning to Jesus’ listeners, those in the 1st century, and you and me today, that the rich and wealthy will find themselves in some horrific hellfire of an afterlife. If I read his reading correctly, what King is suggesting is that Dives started creating his own hell the moment that he walked past Lazarus and couldn't see him as a brother, a fellow human being, and one who was clearly a human being in deep need. Dives didn’t go to hell after he died because of what he did or didn’t do on earth – minimizing the maximum and maximizing the minimum—no, Dives was already in hell when he died, a hell that looked, smelled and tasted fine because he had all the money and privilege in the world to make what he was doing look elegant and pretty, but really was building the hell that he wakes up into all too late.
This then is the tragedy that isn’t the end of the story, but rather the tragedy that begins the story that is revealed at the end of his life. The psalmist in Psalm 14 begins by saying “fools say to themselves, ‘there is no God.’” I think that Jesus is echoing the Psalmist by suggesting where God is in this story: fools say to themselves, I have no need for others. Or to put it in a different way: I have no need for those whom I consider the Other, those not like me, those whose lives are so different from mine that I cannot recognize the humanity, the divine spark, in them. What Jesus says through this story is that it is in this Other, this person whom we do not see, whom we do not want to see as God’s beloved, that God comes to us, where God dwells most presently, beckoning us to respond. For Dives, the destitute Lazarus was God coming as the Other; for some, Lazarus is someone with a disability or illness who threatens our fantasy of everlasting health and ablebodiedness. Lazarus is the one consigned to the margins of the social worlds that you and I inhabit and have built up: those pushed to the edges because of their sexuality, their race, their undocumented status, their particular faith or lack of it. Those whom we know dwell amongst us, but for one reason or another we cannot bring ourselves to bring around our table, but rather keep at arm’s length, their difference so great, their suffering so vast that we’d rather bunker up, close the door, so that we can keep up the pretense that the world that we have built just so will remain that way.
You see, God calls you and me to attend to and care for our poorer sisters and brothers, those in our community that have felt the pang of ostracism, not only because it is the just thing to do, not only because in doing so we alleviate individual and collective suffering—make no mistake, these are good things. God calls you and me to work for justice and dignity for all human beings, which means that we fight for shelter, food, healthcare, for those who have the least. But just as important, perhaps more importantly, you and I are called to look at, engage, and attend to the Lazaruses in our lives because when we truly see Lazarus for who he is—however and whoever Lazarus is in your and my life—then we will have emerged from our hells and begun to walk into the field of God. God comes to us as Lazarus, vulnerable, suffering, and in doing so invites us to tend and care, not just to help the less fortunate, but to transform our hearts into the heart of God. We don’t need Lazarus resurrected to prove to us that this is what God’s realm looks like: Abraham tell Dives that his family should look to Moses and the prophets. And if you and I do so, when you and I embrace what the prophets proclaim, then we will have experienced what Dives unfortunately never does: what Lutheran priest and author Nadia Bolz-Weber, riffing off the prophet Jeremiah, calls a “divine heart transplant,” where God takes our hearts of stone, hearts of stone created by the idolatries of wealth, accumulation, the false sense of fear and security, and replaces them with hearts of flesh that beat for God’s people and for God who comes to us as Lazarus.
The late great poet Audre Lorde once addressed a group of feminist activists and concluded her speech with the following: “I urge each one of us here to reach down into that deep place of knowledge inside herself and touch that terror and loathing of any difference that lives there. See whose face it wears.” Jesus invites you and me to meet Lazarus at our doorsteps, the ones under our noses that we have trouble seeing, and beckons us to see in the one in front of us suffering the God who suffers with and as Lazarus. Jesus calls us to come out of the hells of our self-imposed alienation, our gated communities and gated hearts, so that we can beat warm hearts of flesh to help heal God’s beautiful broken world, and to heal our beautiful broken selves. Like Moses and the prophets, Jesus implores us to undergo divine heart transplants so that as we care for all the Lazaruses in our lives, we might all find ourselves in Abraham’s bosom, on earth as it is in heaven.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

